Lack of Leadership Hurting England

Martin Johnson

Martin Johnson

Something that stood out for me in this past weekend’s match up between Ireland and England was a severe lack of leadership on the English side. I’ve never cared for Steve Borthwick for captain and lately he’s been a bit of a ghost as player too.

Week after week, it seems as though Martin Johnson is still the skipper for England as he is the one answering all of the questions and making comments such as, “we should have adjusted to this” and “we needed to be doing that”. The on field adjustments that Johnson is speaking of are things that are supposed to be taken care of ON the pitch, not after the match has ended. Johnson does deserve some criticism for his sides play of late, but I feel that he’s taking a bit too much. Where is the leadership on this team?

If it’s not Johnson taking the brunt of the criticism, it’s Johnny Wilkinson. I understand Wilko is susceptible to extra criticism given his talismanic position within English rugby. But I am so sick of him having to defend his teams play and his own when he is far the cause of England’s woes.

Ireland are a great example of leadership in world rugby at the moment. Brian O’Driscoll is always in command of his side and Paul O’Connell provides excellent back up, keeping the forwards focused.

This team needs a leader and it is not Steve Borthwick. I always admired Tom Croft for his work rate and energy and thought he was well suited for the captaincy. He’s young and a bit inexperienced, but I just can’t come up with another player to lead this team. Croft hasn’t seen any action in the 6 Nations though. Any suggestions for a new English captain?

Tags: , ,

4 Responses to “Lack of Leadership Hurting England”

  1. Vic Drover says:

    Unlike most of the pundits, I thought Danny Care had a great game and seems certainly vocal enough to captain the squad.

  2. Bonzo says:

    I can’t comment on his leadership qualities, but his game was
    dreadful in my opinion. He was very slow getting to the breakdown
    and his delivery to Wilko was terrible. He also gave up a
    mindless penalty when he dumped O’Leary. Despite what poeple have
    said, Lawrence made the right call. He awarded a penalty to
    England for O’Leary holding the ball, then reversed it for the
    retaliation. It was standard law book stuff.

  3. Vic Drover says:

    I think O’Leary either intentionally or accidentally fell over. He was being a douche bag to Care all day. Care could have kept his cool a little better though. Poor form to let O’Leary get to him. And the ref should be penalizing players who prevent a team from taking a quick tap.

    As soon as Care left, Ireland scored. ’nuff said.

  4. Josh Houston says:

    He got the better of Care by purposefully trying to frustrate
    him. He was penalised, it was reversed because of the
    retaliation. O’Leary never did it again. Smart.

Leave a Reply

Writers & Interns Wanted


  • Rugby news from Scrum.com Visit Scrum.com for up-to-the-minute rugby news, breaking rugby news, live rugby commentary, minute-by-minute commentary, rugby video, rugby audio and features.